MarginNote for visual study and recall. Omphalis for reading and synthesis.
Choose MarginNote when you want to turn a textbook into a visual map and a review deck. Choose Omphalis when your question spans papers, articles and talks, and you want to develop your own account with the passages behind it close at hand.
In Omphalis, read or listen to a source, open an explanation beside an unfamiliar idea, and keep a note on the passage. Bring related sources into a notebook, ask a question with citations, check the evidence and write what you think. MarginNote 5 also offers contextual questions, linked notes and multiple documents; the difference is how you want to work, not whether either product can help you understand.
14-day trial, no card required. Includes 150 comprehension units, 200 Ask voice minutes and 15 assistant answers a day. After that, Free stays free. See plan allowances.
Disclosure: this comparison is written by Omphalis about its own product, so it is not a neutral review. We are not paid by MarginNote or by anyone else to be compared favourably, this page carries no affiliate links, and every claim about MarginNote is checked against their own public documentation. Read the full disclosures, and tell us if something here has gone out of date.
MarginNote and Omphalis compared on sources, notes, returning and pricing
Compared on
MarginNote
Omphalis
Working across selected sources
Keep documents, linked excerpts and notes in a Study Set; organize their relationships in cards and mind maps. MarginNote also offers contextual chat.
Gather selected sources, passage notes and your own writing in a notebook. Ask across that material, inspect citations and return to the evidence later.
Sources supported
PDF and EPUB, plus web pages and video. A Study Set keeps a course's PDFs, EPUBs, lecture video, and lecture audio together. iPhone, iPad, and Mac, offline, with no Windows client.
PDFs and papers, articles, podcasts, and YouTube talks, each opened as one cleaned reading page with a section map. A web app with a Mac app and iOS and Android apps.
Highlights and notes
Each highlight becomes one card: a highlight on the page, a node in a mind map, and a flashcard reviewed on an FSRS schedule. Anki decks import and export.
Keep typed notes on passages and gather selected marks into a notebook with sources, questions and your own writing.
Returning to a passage
One click from any card opens the PDF at that page and highlight, and Title Link lights up a past concept on a new page as a backlink.
The Marks rail and the Library Marks list reopen the passage with the sentences around it still in view.
Pricing model
The US App Store lists Pro at $12.99 once, Max Annual at $16.99 and Max Forever at $51.99, alongside upgrade and subscription options. Check device entitlements, credits and your regional offer before purchase.
Free plan. Pro is $9 a month or $90 a year, with a 14-day trial, no card required (150 comprehension units, 200 Ask voice minutes and 15 assistant answers a day). PDFs are read during the trial and on every plan above Free, from your units.
Start with the task you have in mind
Study a textbook with maps and scheduled review
In MarginNote
MarginNote 5 keeps PDF highlights linked to mind-map cards and review decks. Its templates organize reading, handwriting and recall, with FSRS spaced repetition and native Apple Pencil support. It also supports contextual chat and multiple documents.
Use Omphalis for the reasoning you want to retain: read the source, question a claim, check a cited answer and write your own note on the passage. Its section map navigates a source; it does not replace a mind map or an FSRS review deck.
Come back to a highlight with the text around it
In MarginNote
Every card is pinned to the page it came from, and from any card one click opens the PDF at that page and highlight. Title Link goes a step further: each card's title becomes a keyword, so when a concept from your past notes appears in a new document, it lights up on the new page as an automatic backlink. Wiki-style card links and global search keep an old highlight findable.
The mark stays on the passage in the cleaned reading page rather than moving into a card. The Marks rail lists your marks beside the open source, and in the Library Marks list, selecting a mark shows it in context, and Open article returns you to that passage with the sentences around it still in view. The note you left says why it mattered.
Connect a paper with a related article or talk
In MarginNote
MarginNote 5 supports PDFs, EPUBs, audio and video, side-by-side documents, linked cards and chat. Extend still provides inline, margin or folded writing space. Answers can be kept as cards or arranged in a mind map.
Bring selected sources and the marks you kept into a notebook. Ask one question across that material, open the citations to check the passages, and write your own interpretation beside the sources. Reopen the notebook later to continue the question. Omphalis uses extracted PDF text, so keep the original for figures, equations and tables. PDF reading needs a paid plan or the trial.
Where a mark takes you back
MarginNote moves an excerpt into a card you can arrange and review. An Omphalis mark stays a way back into the source. This Omphalis example is the Library Marks list, grouped by source: five highlights kept from an article, one with a note beneath it, and Open beside each source to go back into it.
Marks collected in the library, grouped by source. Select a mark to see it in context and open the source at that passage.
Select the image to see the detail.
Which would I try?
MarginNote, for maps and flashcards
Keep MarginNote if a textbook has to become a mind map, an outline, and a deck you review on a schedule, or if you write by hand on an iPad as you read. Its card model joins annotation, visual organization and scheduled review. MarginNote also works offline and brings Anki decks in and out.
Bring selected sources and the marks you kept into a notebook. Ask one question across that material, open the citations to check the passages, and write your own interpretation beside the sources. Reopen the notebook later to continue the question. Try it with one paper and one related talk. Omphalis has web, Mac, iOS and Android apps; features differ by platform.
The two can sit side by side: keep your maps and decks in MarginNote, and read the papers, articles, and talks you need to understand closely in Omphalis. Open the same hard section in both and see which one gets you through it. When a paper is part of a question you will keep working on for weeks, see how to come back to that question with your notes and sources beside it.
Yes, for reading and research across selected sources. In Omphalis you can explain a passage, ask cited questions, keep your own source-linked notes and build a notebook across papers, articles and talks. Choose MarginNote when original-page handwriting, visual excerpt maps and scheduled flashcard review are essential. Both products offer questions and linked notes; compare how you want to work.
Which highlight apps keep the surrounding text?
Both of these do, in different ways. In MarginNote every highlight becomes a card pinned to its page, one click opens the PDF at that page and highlight, and MarginNote says the surrounding material is one tap away during review. In Omphalis the mark stays on the passage in the cleaned reading page; the Marks rail and the Library Marks list reopen that passage with the sentences around it in view, and a note can record why it stopped you.
What is a good study app for dense PDFs?
The right app depends on how you study. If you learn by turning a textbook into cards, maps, and scheduled review (MarginNote describes medical school, law school, and professional exams among its uses), MarginNote is built for that on iPhone, iPad, and Mac. If you learn by getting through the argument of a dense paper or report and returning to the hard parts, Omphalis gives you a section map, explanations beside the passage, marks with notes, narration you can listen to, and Ask with citations. Omphalis shows extracted text, so keep the original PDF for figures, tables, and equations.
Does Omphalis make flashcards or mind maps?
Omphalis has no visual mind-map canvas or specialist spaced-repetition system. Course builder can create study material from a long saved document on paid plans or the trial. The Omphalis section map shows the parts of a long piece so you can move through it; it is not a map you build from your excerpts. If you want those study tools, MarginNote has them, and it imports and exports Anki decks.
Does Omphalis run on the same devices as MarginNote?
Not the same way. MarginNote 5 is sold through the App Store for iPhone, iPad, and Mac, with a separate Mac-only download, and says it has no Windows client. The US App Store lists Pro at $12.99 once, Max Annual at $16.99 and Max Forever at $51.99, alongside other offers. Check the device entitlement and credit requirements for the purchase you select. Omphalis is a web app with a Mac app, iOS and Android apps, and a browser extension; there is no Windows app. Omphalis Free is $0 and Pro is $9 a month or $90 a year, with a 14-day trial, no card required (150 comprehension units, 200 Ask voice minutes and 15 assistant answers a day). PDFs are read during the trial and on every plan above Free, from your units. US prices checked October 29, 2026. Purchase options and credits vary by channel; check the current listing.