Compare

Compare how you read, connect sources and keep your own thinking.

Choose for the work you want to finish: understanding a source, building an evidence-backed note, mapping ideas, managing citations or studying for recall. Omphalis combines selected-source reading, cited questions and source-linked notes; specialist tools may be better for handwriting, reference management or spaced repetition.

Start free

14-day trial, no card required. Includes 150 comprehension units, 200 Ask voice minutes and 15 assistant answers a day. After that, Free stays free. See plan allowances.

Disclosure: this comparison is written by Omphalis about its own product, so it is not a neutral review. We are not paid by the tools named here or by anyone else to be compared favourably, this page carries no affiliate links, and every claim about the tools named here is checked against their own public documentation. Read the full disclosures, and tell us if something here has gone out of date.

Checked against official documentation on September 11, 2026, the Snipd, LiquidText, MarginNote, Elicit, Mindgrasp, and Eightify entries on September 29, 2026, the Recall entry on October 17, 2026, the Zotero, Goodnotes, Perplexity, and Adobe Acrobat entries on October 20, 2026, the Speechify entry on October 22, 2026, and the ElevenReader entry on October 29, 2026. The October 29 audit refreshed selected claims, including MarginNote 5, Matter, Glasp, Recall pricing and Perplexity limits. Our suggestions about fit are our judgment.

Updated

What does reading in Omphalis look like?

Open an article, use its sections to find your place, and open an explanation when a passage needs more context. You can ask a follow-up question and keep a note attached to the passage.

Open an explanation, read it beside the passage, then carry on.

How do these tools compare at a glance?

Tool workflows, reasons to compare Omphalis, and trade-offs
ToolWhat it is built forReasons to compare and trade-offs
OmphalisRead and listen across selected sources, ask cited questions and keep your own passage notes and notebook writing.Check the trade-offs: extracted PDF text, no ink canvas or reference manager, and processing allowances. PDFs require a paid plan or trial. See plans.
Readwise ReaderSaved reading, highlights and listening, with Ghostreader to explain a passage and answer questions across your library with citations.You want a notebook that keeps selected sources, passage notes, cited questions and your own writing together. You can try it with a read-only Reader import on a paid plan.
NotebookLMStudying a set of sources: questions with citations, study guides, mind maps and Audio Overviews. Now called Gemini Notebook.You want to move between close reading, cited questions across selected sources and your own source-linked notes. Both products support multi-source questions.
RecallSaving articles, videos, podcasts, PDFs, and notes, then summarizing, tagging, and linking them, with quizzes on a paid plan.You want to develop and revisit a question through its source passages and your own notes, with selected material in a notebook.
HeptabaseCards and whiteboards, with PDF reading, highlights and questions about your sources.You prefer a source-linked notebook for your question and evidence. Choose Heptabase when arranging cards on whiteboards is central to your thinking.
PocketA read-later list for articles. Mozilla shut Pocket down on July 8, 2025.You kept an existing export or source URLs and want to turn that saved reading into notes and evidence you can use again.
OmnivoreThe hosted cloud app was deprecated in November 2024. The project remains on GitHub for people who want to self-host.You want hosted mixed-format reading, questions and notes. Omphalis has no self-hosted edition or advertised bulk Omnivore importer.
InstapaperSaving articles as clean text that syncs across devices and reads offline. Premium adds full-text search, a permanent archive and a PDF reader.You want contextual explanations, cited questions and notebooks across selected reading. Check offline and Kindle requirements before choosing.
MatterA reading queue for articles, newsletters, PDFs, YouTube and podcast transcripts, with listening, highlights and Premium Co-Reader.You want to develop a continuing question with selected sources and your own notes in a notebook. Matter also offers Co-Reader and media transcripts.
SpeechifyReading almost any text aloud on every device, with many voices and languages and high speeds.You want listening, passage notes and cited questions around a research project. Compare voice choices, speed and allowances for your own material.
ElevenReaderTurning books, PDFs and articles into audio in a voice you choose, with a large audiobook catalog and Voice Chat questions while you listen.You want listening, passage notes and cited questions across selected sources in a notebook. Choose ElevenReader for its voices, audiobooks and faster playback.
GlaspSocial highlights, summaries, PDF and page/video chat, audio transcription and exports; private highlights need a paid plan.You want private-by-default marks and a notebook for selected sources and your interpretation. Glasp also offers chat and summaries, plus community discovery.
SnipdA podcast player for iOS and Android: triple-tap your headphones to save a moment with its audio, transcript and a written summary.You want to connect an episode with articles and papers, check cited answers and keep your own notes. Snipd offers headphone capture and podcast review.
LiquidTextA PDF and document workspace for iPad, Mac and Windows, where excerpts you drag onto a workspace link back to the source.You want to compare papers, articles and talks through questions and typed source-linked notes. Choose LiquidText for an excerpt canvas and ink.
MarginNoteTurning each highlight into a card that is also a mind-map node and a flashcard on a spaced-repetition schedule, on iPhone, iPad and Mac.You want reading and synthesis across selected sources in a notebook. Choose MarginNote for Pencil, visual excerpt maps and scheduled review.
ElicitFinding and screening academic papers: search by meaning, and systematic reviews with sentence-level citations.You want to understand a claim and develop your own synthesis across selected papers and other media. Elicit provides literature search and systematic-review tools.
ZoteroCollecting references, citing in Word, LibreOffice, and Google Docs, and annotating the PDFs in the library, including Zotero 10 Reading Mode and Read Aloud.You want to add passage explanations, mixed-source questions and a notebook to selected papers imported read-only. Keep Zotero for reference management.
Adobe AcrobatMaking, editing, and signing PDFs, with an assistant that answers questions about the files you open.You want report reading, cited questions and personal notes across sources. Keep original-page tools for editing, signatures, figures and layout.
PerplexityCited answers from the web, your files, and connected apps, with Projects that keep searches and files together.You want to keep your interpretation beside chosen source passages and return to it. Perplexity also supports ongoing research across web results and files.
GoodnotesHandwritten notes on a tablet, with PDF markup, searchable handwriting, audio synced to your writing, and flashcards from your notes.You want typed research notes tied to papers, articles and talks, with questions across a notebook. Choose Goodnotes for handwriting and an original-page canvas.
MindgraspGenerating notes, summaries, flashcards and quizzes from lectures, PDFs, slides, audio, video and YouTube links.You want to investigate lecture claims across related readings and keep your own source-linked interpretation. Mindgrasp offers generated exam practice.
EightifyA written summary of a YouTube video with key insights and timestamped navigation, for deciding quickly whether it is worth watching.You want to question a talk, keep timestamped notes and compare it with other reading. Eightify keeps quick takeaways in the YouTube workflow.
Obsidian / NotionWriting notes, with web clippers that save pages into an Obsidian vault or a Notion workspace.You want to read a source, ask about it and gather the passages you want to write from.
Raindrop.ioSaving and finding links, with highlights kept alongside your bookmarks.You also want to work through the text or transcript.

Where do the other tools fit?

Recall

Recall saves articles, YouTube videos, podcasts, PDFs, and notes, then summarizes them, tags them, and links them. Free is $0 with 10 summaries per month and unlimited notes. Plus is $10 a month billed yearly, or $12 billed monthly, and adds chat with what you saved or the open web, quizzes, and spaced repetition. Max is $38 a month billed yearly, or $48 billed monthly.

You want to develop and revisit a question through its source passages and your own notes, with selected material in a notebook.

Heptabase

Heptabase combines cards and whiteboards with PDF reading, highlights and questions about your sources. Space search can find relevant cards and whiteboards for an answer.

You prefer a source-linked notebook for your question and evidence. Choose Heptabase when arranging cards on whiteboards is central to your thinking.

Omnivore

Omnivore's hosted cloud app was deprecated in November 2024. The project remains on GitHub for people who want to self-host. Omphalis is hosted software, not an open-source fork and not Wallabag.

You want hosted mixed-format reading, questions and notes. Omphalis has no self-hosted edition or advertised bulk Omnivore importer.

Matter

A reading queue for articles, newsletters, PDFs, YouTube and podcast transcripts, with listening, highlights and Premium Co-Reader.

You want to develop a continuing question with selected sources and your own notes in a notebook. Matter also offers Co-Reader and media transcripts.

Speechify

Speechify reads text aloud on iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome, Edge, the web, Mac, and Windows. Premium lists 1,000+ voices, 60+ languages, speeds up to 5x, and Scan & Listen for printed pages, and Enhanced Skipping can leave out footnotes, citations, and URLs. Free reads at up to 1.5x with 10 voices, and Premium is $29 a month billed monthly or $139 a year.

You want listening, passage notes and cited questions around a research project. Compare voice choices, speed and allowances for your own material.

ElevenReader

ElevenReader turns books, PDFs, articles and other files into audio in 1,000+ voices, with a catalog of 200,000+ audiobooks. Free includes 10 hours of text to audio a month and speeds up to 4x. Ultra is $11 a month or $99 a year and adds unlimited text to audio for your imports, offline downloads, custom voices and smart file imports. Voice Chat, a beta in the phone apps, answers questions about what you are listening to.

You want listening, passage notes and cited questions across selected sources in a notebook. Choose ElevenReader for its voices, audiobooks and faster playback.

Glasp

Glasp combines social highlights and export with PDF and page/video chat, summaries and audio transcription. Free highlights are public; private highlights and allowances depend on the paid plan.

You want private-by-default marks and a notebook for selected sources and your interpretation. Glasp also offers chat and summaries, plus community discovery.

Snipd

Snipd is a podcast player for iOS and Android built around snips: triple-tap your headphones to save a moment with its audio, transcript and a written summary. Snips sync to Readwise, Notion, Obsidian and other note apps, and the free plan covers unlimited listening with generated features on two episodes a week.

You want to connect an episode with articles and papers, check cited answers and keep your own notes. Snipd offers headphone capture and podcast review.

LiquidText

LiquidText is a PDF and document workspace for iPad, Mac, and Windows where you drag excerpts onto a workspace, each linked back to the source with a single click. Pro 2023 and LIVE add ink, links drawn between any two points, and documents viewed in parallel.

You want to compare papers, articles and talks through questions and typed source-linked notes. Choose LiquidText for an excerpt canvas and ink.

MarginNote

MarginNote 5 combines PDF highlights, linked cards, mind maps and FSRS review, with handwriting, multiple documents and contextual questions. Extend retains inline, margin and folded writing space. Available on iPhone, iPad and Mac; purchases and credits depend on the plan and channel.

You want reading and synthesis across selected sources in a notebook. Choose MarginNote for Pencil, visual excerpt maps and scheduled review.

Elicit

Elicit is a research assistant that searches more than 138 million academic papers and 545,000 clinical trials by meaning rather than exact keywords. The Elicit systematic review workflow screens papers, extracts data with supporting quotes, and produces reports with sentence-level citations.

You want to understand a claim and develop your own synthesis across selected papers and other media. Elicit provides literature search and systematic-review tools.

Zotero

Zotero is a free, open-source tool for collecting, organizing, annotating, citing, and sharing research. It runs on Mac, Windows, Linux, iOS, and Android, cites in Word, LibreOffice, and Google Docs with over 9,000 styles, and shares group libraries at no cost. Zotero 10 adds Reading Mode for PDFs and a smarter Read Aloud. The program is free. File storage is 300 MB free, then $20 a year for 2 GB.

You want to add passage explanations, mixed-source questions and a notebook to selected papers imported read-only. Keep Zotero for reference management.

Adobe Acrobat

Adobe Acrobat creates, edits, converts, combines, fills, and signs PDFs, and Reader is free. Acrobat's assistant answers questions about up to 10 files at once and marks the sources it used with numbers. Studio, which includes the assistant, is US$24.99 a month on an annual plan billed monthly.

You want report reading, cited questions and personal notes across sources. Keep original-page tools for editing, signatures, figures and layout.

Perplexity

Perplexity answers questions from the web with inline citations in every answer. Pro adds deep research, a choice of models, and search across the web, your files, and connected apps. Projects, formerly Spaces, keep searches, files, and instructions together, with up to 10,000 files and 5 GB per Project, up to 100 MB per file. Free is $0 and Pro is $17 a month billed annually.

You want to keep your interpretation beside chosen source passages and return to it. Perplexity also supports ongoing research across web results and files.

Goodnotes

Goodnotes is a note-taking app built around natural handwriting, on iPad, iPhone, Mac, Android, Windows, and the web. Handwriting is searchable, PDFs can be handwritten on, highlighted, and shared, audio stays synced to what you wrote, and Study Sets make flashcards from your notes. A free plan is free forever with limits, and Essential is $11.99 a year.

You want typed research notes tied to papers, articles and talks, with questions across a notebook. Choose Goodnotes for handwriting and an original-page canvas.

Mindgrasp

Mindgrasp is a study tool that takes recorded lectures, PDFs, slides, audio, video, and YouTube links and generates notes, summaries, flashcards, and quizzes, with a tutor you can ask about the material. The Mindgrasp Chrome extension pulls class material from Canvas, Blackboard, or any website.

You want to investigate lecture claims across related readings and keep your own source-linked interpretation. Mindgrasp offers generated exam practice.

Eightify

Eightify is a Chrome extension, with iOS and Android apps, that writes a summary of a YouTube video with key insights, timestamped navigation, and a top comments overview. Eightify also generates transcripts you can download as plain text or SRT, in more than 40 languages.

You want to question a talk, keep timestamped notes and compare it with other reading. Eightify keeps quick takeaways in the YouTube workflow.

Obsidian / Notion

Obsidian and Notion can both bring web content into your notes. Obsidian's Web Clipper saves locally to your vault and includes a reader and highlighter. Notion's clipper saves pages into a workspace or database.

Keep using the place where you like to write. Try Omphalis for reading a source, asking about it and gathering the passages you want to write from.

Raindrop.io

Raindrop lets you highlight saved web pages and keep those highlights with your bookmarks.

If saving and finding links is the whole job, a bookmark manager may be enough. Try Omphalis when you also want to work through the text or transcript.

Looking for a home for old Pocket saves? Compare Pocket with Omphalis or see the Pocket guide. For working through a difficult source yourself, see the NotebookLM alternative. Comparing sources rather than tools? See how to compare what your sources say in a notebook.

How do you test the same source in both?

Choose a passage you find difficult. Read it, ask the question you have, follow the answer back to the passage it cites, then leave a note. A test like that tells you more than a feature checklist.

Try the reader without an account →

Which tool fits the job you have?

Which of these tools have shut down?

Pocket and the hosted Omnivore app have both shut down. Mozilla shut Pocket down on July 8, 2025, and Pocket exports closed on November 12, 2025, according to Mozilla's help article. Omnivore's hosted cloud app was deprecated in November 2024, and the Omnivore project remains on GitHub for people who want to self-host. Omphalis is hosted software, not an open-source fork of Omnivore.

Which tool fits if saving articles is the whole job?

If saving articles is the whole job, a read-later app or a bookmark manager may be enough. Instapaper saves articles as clean text, syncs across devices and reads offline. Matter is an Apple-first read-later app with strong text-to-speech and newsletters. Raindrop.io keeps highlights with your bookmarks. Try Omphalis for reading that leads to source-linked questions, notes and synthesis across selected material.

Which tool fits for studying a set of sources or preparing for an exam?

NotebookLM, now called Gemini Notebook, lets you ask questions across a set of sources with citations and create study guides, mind maps and Audio Overviews. Mindgrasp generates notes, summaries, flashcards and quizzes from lectures and readings. MarginNote makes each highlight a flashcard reviewed on a spaced-repetition schedule. Omphalis supports reading, cited questions and your own synthesis in notebooks. It is not a general flashcard or exam-practice replacement; its separate Course Builder has its own scope and plan conditions.

Which tool fits for podcasts and YouTube talks?

Snipd is a podcast player built around snips: triple-tap your headphones to save a moment with its audio, transcript and a written summary. Eightify writes a summary of a YouTube video with key insights and timestamped navigation, which helps you decide quickly whether a video is worth watching. Omphalis opens an episode or a talk you already chose as a transcript with a section map, explanations and marks on the transcript, in the same Library as your articles and PDFs.

Which tool fits for academic papers?

Elicit is built for finding and screening papers: it searches more than 138 million academic papers by meaning, and its systematic review workflow produces reports with sentence-level citations. Zotero keeps the references, the citations, and the PDF highlights, and Zotero 10 adds Reading Mode and Read Aloud. LiquidText lets you drag excerpts from a PDF onto a workspace, and MarginNote makes each highlight a card in a mind map. Keep Zotero for citations. Omphalis is for reading the papers you keep, with explanations beside hard passages and answers cited to your library.

Which of these tools answer questions with citations?

Readwise Reader, NotebookLM, Elicit and Omphalis all answer with citations, in different ways. Readwise Reader's Ghostreader answers questions across your library with citations. NotebookLM answers questions across a notebook's sources with citations. Elicit produces reports with sentence-level citations. In Omphalis, Ask answers with citations that lead back to the passage each point came from, including when you ask out loud in the web app: the answer is spoken and its citations appear on screen.

Do I have to stop using my notes app?

No. You can keep writing in Obsidian or Notion. Obsidian's Web Clipper saves web pages locally to your vault, with a reader and highlighter, and Notion's clipper saves pages into a workspace or database. Keep using the place where you like to write, and try Omphalis for reading a source, asking about it and gathering the passages you want to write from.

Written by Last updated